16 Comments
User's avatar
Tony Pomfret's avatar

If that is the best Luxon & Co and Chippy can do, then we are really in a pickle! No words about fast rising inequality. No words about challenging the power companies and breaking up the gentailers. No words about the duopoly of supermarkets. No word about help to people on a fixed income like super. No vision for solving our static, low wage economy and stopping the flight of talented people overseas. No words about our crumbling health services. No words about the people stuck on welfare who want to work but can’t because of our too low minimum wage. No words about the appalling obesity epidemic and cheap junk foods. No words about building more affordable housing to tackle the over priced housing market. On and on! Do these people have any ideas? Oh maybe policies for 2029! Really? But that will be another election cycle away! No words about a 4 year term which most people would be happy with. No real policies about the water infrastructure renewal the country needs. And don’t even talk about Air NZ and the awful decisions Luxon made when he ran it! Ferries and wasted time and money? Oh my, we really are in a pickle!

Helen Raskin's avatar

Actually that is exactly the sort of speech someone who is sorted would give. Completely divorced from the reality of most of Aotearoa. And boring as hell.

James Wilkes's avatar

What a state that state of the nation address was in. Luxon sounded like he was in the middle of an excruciating narcissistic injury episode. It was clear to anyone watching that he didn’t believe what he was saying. It was just rehearsed white noise. What was National thinking? How on earth did they think parachuting in a status quo lover with no political experience and a personality only a mother could love was ever going to be a good idea? And on the left, mumbo-jumbo, sausage roll advocacy, and crickets. I will admit to a WTF moment when Hipkins advised the pundits that they had already released some major policies. Wow, they must have sailed under my radar. Can it get any more underwhelming? If they keep this level of boring up, the last one out switch the light off myth, might become a reality. Oh, and Willis looked bored out of her mind.

Grant Duncan's avatar

Made me laugh, James!

Phil's avatar

Hmm. This makes me think about how boredom erodes vigilance with information and votes. You are right. Voters get 'bored into submission,' low turnout hands power to whoever sounds most predictable. They check out, forget govt even exists until next cycle.

Not going to lie, even I have tuned out due apathy. Which is something I know is bad. Maybe its human nature we are missing in this equation?

Then again, is the reverse any healthier? As in outrage and manufactured consent?

I know I'm playing with extremes which isn't fair to your actual point. Thoughts? Is boredom the real disinfo weapon here, or does constant drama keep us more trapped?

either way, 2026 is going to be.... eventful. Glad we can rant about it on substack.

Kevin Mayes's avatar

While the intention may be to bore the electorate into supporting (or defaulting to by ballot-box no-shows) a second term, All the indications are that, if the current Nat-led coalition return to office, the demolition of public services, privatisation of Crown assets and legislation / treaties designed to make the right-shift irreversible will continue at an accelerated pace.

Despite maybe I should be telling myself to "be careful what I wish for", I'm pinning my hopes on the inevitable major global economic melt-down triggered by an asset price crash arriving in the interim. My feeling is that the public will not look favourably on more 2008-style bank baleouts when they've had to suffer the rigours of service cuts and a falling standard of living over the last 2 or more years. Having said that, the mechanism by which baleouts take place, QE bond purchases followed by QT bond resales at huge net loss to the Crown- is quite invisible to the general public- the losses occurring a long time after the peak of the crisis and over a long spread of time.

The problem with the scenario I speak of as a potential electoral device for a Labour campaign is that Labour itself is part of a global liberal-democratic tendency ( along with US Dems, UK Labour, Euro Social-Democrats etc.) that sees the interests of the finance sector as core to the stability of the Neoliberal world order. It is therefore unthinkable that NZ Labour will countenance any proposal that doesn't give the finance sector everything it says it needs to survive such a shock.

Possibly the Greens could step into the limelight with a fiery 'bankrupt (and nationalise) the banks, bale out the deposit holders' platform, but I really don't think they have the authoritarian mana for the job.

I'm considering (but certainly not advocating for) the possibility of a 'Grand Coalition of the Centre' or 'Government of National Unity' between Labour and National, whose entire focus would be on preserving the (unpreservable imo) systemic status quo without the irritations of the radical Right being pushed by ACT or those of the Left promoted by the Greens.

Janfrie Wakim's avatar

Well put Grant. Keep thinking about the Reith lectures for 2025 Moral Revolution by Rutger Bregman and real leadership.

He delves into the current 'age of immorality', explore a growing trend for unseriousness among elites, and ask how we can follow history’s example and assemble small, committed groups to spark positive change.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/v78MKsCWHxw0l0PwMn4R0R/bbc-reith-lectures-2025-moral-revolution

• A Time of Monsters

• How To Start a Moral Revolution

• A Conspiracy of Decency

• Fighting for Humanity in the Age of the Machine

Grant Duncan's avatar

Thanks for that link, Janfrie. I'll have a listen.

John Philpin's avatar

At least pickles have a tang - a certain spice. He also speaks and acts as if planet earth is working in BAU mode.

But it’s not just climatic upheaval anymore — it’s political, military, social, institutional .. Luxon and the whole system operates in 8 wire mode. I commend readers here to pop over and read today’s Antipodean Musings .. I wonder who could be New Zealand’s ‘Carney’ … none of the Chris’s — that’s for sure.

Grant Duncan's avatar

Carney did a great speech at WEF! No one in NZ could do that.

John Philpin's avatar

> “Every country has the government it deserves."

💬 Joseph de Maistre

Mike Henden's avatar

Apathetic Kiwis = Apathetic Government…

Kiwi Rebel's avatar

Waitangi provided a little more meat on the bare bones. Just. It’s funny how our national day brings out the worst in people, jostling for position in unfamiliar surrounds.

garry wycherley's avatar

Why do we need to know you have a PHD ?

John Maidment's avatar

New Zealand can’t afford (socially, economically or environmentally) yet another three years of bland, status quo, uninspiring, unimaginative, politicians. But if so could the last person to leave please turn the lights out.

Grant Duncan's avatar

That last person will probably be me, John!